Saurabh Arora

Saurabh_Arora_Icon

The Community Aspect of Learning

Recently, I completed the introductory courses of Accounting and Finance as part of Pre-MBA requirement. I couldn’t help resist the temptation of comparing the Pre-MBA coursework with MBA Mondays series started by prolific blogger and a VC, Fred Wilson.

  • Pre-MBA Finance and Accounting online courses aim to teach fundamental accounting and financial ratio concepts. A hypothetical company is constructed and the concepts are explained from the view point of the life cycle of the company from raising money to producing goods to financing to selling to customers.
  • MBA Mondays is a series of blog posts that aims to teach a broad set of fundamental finance concepts. The topics covered range from Present Value of Future Cash Flows to understanding Balance Sheet, Income Statement and Cash Flows to Key Business Metric to understanding risk and return among others.

Pre-MBA courses are more hands on in preparing and maintaining actual financial records of the company while MBA Mondays explains the concepts in very simple terms and stresses the importance of knowing this stuff and hiring an accounting/finance guy to prepare and maintain in the long run. Although both explain the basic concepts there is an importance difference between the two – The Community.

Although the online coursework has no community aspect, many business schools and even companies now position this aspect as a strong selling point to attract potential candidates and employees. And it’s not a superficial aspect but indeed an important one. Having said that, the objective of this post is not to compare the online coursework with the MBA Mondays series but to emphasize the community aspect of learning, particularly taking an example of the online community of AVC blog.

The Community

Fred’s post are no doubt insightful and interesting to read. But that’s half of the story. The depth of the topic is almost always hidden in the comments section. On an average, there are about 60-80 comments per post (guesstimate based on recent posts) but some MBA Mondays post can have as high as 170 comments. I always read Fred’s post twice. One immediately as it’s published (as soon as I read the tweet on Twitter) and another, after a day when the discussion has evolved in the comments section.

Let’s understand the importance of community through some of the actual examples taken from the blog.

a) Sure you can learn accounting concepts but community can help you answer more subtle questions such as how much of financial information to share with employees. What are the best ways to share the information? At what stage companies become creative in their accounting practices? Examples from personal experiences of the members enrich the discussion on hand.

Sharing personal experiences
Sharing personal experiences

b) Members of the community help each other. In the below example, K Harazny explains the concept of Unearned Revenue to ShanaC’s question on accrual accounting in the comments of this post.

Community answers questions
Community answers questions

c) Members provide links to additional resources. One can get all sorts of recommendations ranging from additional books to read for a deeper dive into the topic to the online software for keeping the books.

d) The very nature of the blog ensures the community is interested in entrepreneurship, thereby giving a unique perspective to the comments. In the below comment, JLM provides insight to the “progressive” level of staffing based on the stage of the company.

Progressive level of staffing
Progressive level of staffing

e) Discussions can sometimes be very interesting and bring unique perspective. See this thread for a great discussion between JLM and Tereza on “turnarounds”.

There are more than 5,000 posts on the blog but I have read only 1% or so since I discovered the blog only couple of months ago while researching startup ecosystem in NY as part of business school research. So the above examples could be limited. However, I would love to learn what other aspects of community learning you are excited about?

Enhanced by Zemanta

How to get Google Voice number outside US?

Many people have asked me this question. For the benefit of everyone, am sharing here the steps to get your own Google Voice (GV) number. There is no guarantee that this method will work and this may require some bit of technical competency. But if you know how to install a program and read your email, you should be fine.

I’m not going to detail the benefits of Google Voice but you may want to see a quick short intro video embedded below if you are unfamiliar with the service.

Now, let’s get you a GV number.

Get a US number

Before you can have your own GV number, you would need a US number (why?) that GV can forward the calls to.

Zero Cost Option: The zero cost option is to first get a free SIP number from any of the providers such as FreeWorldDialup or Gizmo or Gtalk2Voip. I would recommend to go for Gtalk2Voip since it will ring your Gtalk for every incoming call. Once you have your SIP number, you can register the SIP number with IPKall. IPKall gives you a local number in Washington state that rings your SIP number whenever someone calls your IPKall number. That’s it, you now have a US number but there are few things to consider with this option:

  • It may take about a week before IPKall gives you a free US number
  • IPKall may release your number unless you make/receive at least one call a month
  • IPKall requires one to enter SIP phoner number and SIP proxy, which you can get from your SIP provider

Dollar a month option: As you might have noticed, the zero cost option requires some bit of technical competency and patience but if you are willing to spend a dollar a month, you can get a US number easily. Sign up on Spokn and get a US number for a dollar/month. Your Spokn number can work with any of the SIP clients (see settings) or download the Spokn client from the Spokn site for Windows Desktop, Mobile, Nokia or Blackberry devices. That’s it, you now have a US number.

Get a Google Voice number

Earlier, one needed an invite in order to register for GV. But recently, Google opened up GV to public with no invitation required. However, there is one small caveat.

Update 10:38 am: Just to clarify, though we’ve opened up sign-ups, Google Voice is still limited to everyone in the U.S. for now.

Since you are outside US and if you try to register for Google Voice, you will get the below message.

Google Voice not available in your country

Google Voice not available in your country

In all probability, Google has tracked your IP and knows that you are accessing the service from a non-US IP address. However, you can use a proxy server in order to circumvent this restriction. Basically, all your requests the browser makes goes through the proxy server and the site you are trying to access believes the requests are coming from the proxy server instead of your computer. Google “free proxy server” and you will find dozens of options available but I would recommend HotSpot Shield. Download the client and run the software. Now, if you try to register for Google Voice, you will be taken to a welcome screen and ask to choose a Google Voice number! Follow the steps and register your US number with the Google Voice number.

If you want, you can now uninstall the HotSpot Shield software since Google doesn’t restrict accessing GV site once you have registered for the service. That’s it. You now have a working Google Voice number!

Fine print: If you choose to go with above steps only to have Google shut your Google Voice account,  I take no responsibility.

Enhanced by Zemanta

The Promise of an Ad Copy

TNT recently ran the promoted tweet of HawthoRNe on twitter. I’m not sure of the economics of the deal but I believe considering the clicks coke ad received on twitter, TNT must have spent a lot of dollars.

Out of my curiosity, I clicked on the promoted tweet (see below gallery) and was taken to the TNT page where I was shown a 15 sec promotion of Bose before the actual promotion of recap of Season 1 (as promised by the ad).  I clicked on the promoted tweet again thinking this time I would see the actual Season 1 recap but to my disappointment I saw the Nature Valley peanut ad.

—- Promoted Tweet Gallery —-

Click on each image to view

At first go, I thought this is a mistake which went against the common logic – No one would want to spend marketing dollars to get viewers on the site and then show them an ad and not the actual product. Unless of course Bose is giving TNT a lot more money for each playback than TNT is spending on getting users on the site. For the sake of argument, let’s assume TNT got more money for each playback as compared to the money spent to get X visitors (assuming some visitors would just leave the site before the ad is run) for each playback.

Revenue (each playback) > Cost (get X visitors for each playback)

This may work for TNT but then it’s a bad user experience. User intends to view the recap of Season 1 and not view a commercial which is not related to Season 1 in any way.

Essentially, the message in the ad has to relate to the landing page the user is taken on clicking the ad. If the ad copy and the landing page are not in sync, it may lead to lower conversions. In some cases, the ad copy and message are partially sync where the user has to perform certain actions on the landing page before arriving at the optimal page (as promised by the ad). In these cases as well, there may be lower conversions. Consider the following example.

I googled “book hotels in goa” and clicked on the Cleartrip ad (you may or may not see the ad if you google now) which promised to book hotels in goa with a 20% instant cash back promotion. If you look (see below gallery) closely at the ad copy, you would notice that the URL is shown as “cleartrip.com/Goa_Hotels” and the ad headline reads “Book Hotels in Goa”. Obviously, one would expect something similar to hotels in Goa on clicking the ad, but the landing page does not even mention Goa! It’s a generic promotion page (see below gallery) where the 20% cash back offer details are mentioned and place to search hotels. At the very least, the city text box on the landing page should have been pre-filled to connect with the ad copy.

—- Cleartrip Google Ad Gallery —-

Click on each image to view

Sometimes, it makes sense to translate and imagine the customer experience offline. Customer would go to a travel agency and ask for hotels in Goa. Agent would ask the dates, category of the hotel and any other preference (near to airport etc) the customer may have in mind. Appropriately, agent would then provide the options and also mention that currently there is 20% cash back on all hotels. Mapping online, it translates to goa hotels listing with option to narrow down hotels while mentioning the 20% cash back offer. In fact, Cleartrip has this page (see below) but it has chosen not to take users directly.

Cleartrip Goa Hotels Listing

Cleartrip Goa Hotels Listing

I would assume they have tried this option but are not getting higher conversions. What do you think?

Enhanced by Zemanta

How to handle unexpected downtime?

Okay, your website  is down. You know it. How do you let others know it? The following outlines the steps to be taken/ processes to be put in place in order to meet the customer expectations in such scenarios. Although, the below is applicable to most online businesses dealing with B2B segments, some of these are applicable to B2C segments (paid) as well.

Accept

First and foremost, it’s important to accept that something is not working. It’s important to understand the problem along three dimensions:

  • Whole web site or subset of features/site not working
  • Completely non-functional or functional but at a sub-optimal level
  • Impacts all users or part of the user base (segment based on geography, type of products etc)

For example, it may so happen that for a set of users with large data sets, feature X is working very slow.

Now that we understand the problem, it’s time to communicate the same.

Communicate

a) To customers

  • Status Page: One should host a separate status page showing status of all products. Usually, it’s a sub-domain (status.your-domain.com) of your domain that your users can go to and see the current status. Ideally, it has to be hosted on a separate server independent of your main production servers and on a different ISP. The status page can take the shape of a blog or one page showing today’s status. See below samples from Google and Dreamhost.
Google Apps Status Dashboard

Google Apps Status Dashboard

Dreamhost Status
Dreamhost Status Blog
  • Email/SMS: One should also email and SMS (with prior consent at the time of sign-up) the user base informing the problem and the likely resolution time (more on this below).
  • Online: If the site is not working partially, a status on the site can be put up (linked to your status page) to notify users about the problem.
  • Social Media: One should update the current status on social media channels such as Twitter and Facebook. Obviously, don’t forget to update the same once resolved.

b) To Sales Team

  • Believe me, there’s nothing more embarrassing than the site not working while giving a demo to a potential client. It’s disastrous for the sales person and the customer may feel that your company is not competent to deliver the services. If possible, host the demo site (can be demo.your-domain.com) on a separate server with a separate database.
  • Many times, if the customer has bought your product/service offline through a direct sales person, he/she will call the sales person first. In this case, salesperson would contact the customer care team resulting in greater number of calls to customer care team. Hence, it’s important that sales team is also communicated about the problem (ideally by SMS/email since they are most likely in the field) at the earliest.

c) To Customer Care Team

  • Generally, if you are providing telephone / online chat support to your paid customers, customer care team is the first one to get notified of the problem by the customer. Hence, it’s important that the customer care team knows about the problem and the likely resolution time.
  • Further, it’s important that the customer care executive (CCE) doesn’t give a cookie-cutter answer such as “Your complaint has been noted and it will be resolved within 24 hours”. A better approach is to say something like, “We are aware of the issue [explain the actual issue with possible root cause - one of the server down etc] and our engineers are working hard to resolve the same. Currently, we are not in a position to give a definite time but we expect it to be resolved in the next X hours. You should receive an email/SMS once it’s resolved”. Generally, X is defined in most organizations as the maximum time for a defined category of problem to be rectified.
  • One a side note, this team should be equipped to give on the spot discounts to customers based on their judgement. For example, the team may be able to give one extra day of service free to customers in order to compensate for the loss. Or X% discount on next purchase.

Customer care team shld talk 2 technical folks 2 know likely resolution time. Book answer of 24 hrs doesn't fly. #Airtel #broadband #failJune 2, 2010 9:22 am via Twitter for iPhone

Post crisis

Needless to say, a root cause analysis is performed by the engineering team once the problem has been resolved. However, what’s more important is to forward some (or most depending on the severity of the problem) of the client conversations (email, phone calls) to everyone in the engineering team. Hearing the customers first hand is the second best way (best is to meet and observe them in person) to know them and better understand the severity of the problem. What may seem a trivial bug to an engineer might be a big problem for (some of) the customers. I may cover this aspect in detail in another post.

Also, in some cases, it maybe important to compensate the impacted users for the duration of the downtime. Say, someone bought your product only for a day and was not able to use for 4 hours. This is generally useful for subscription based products where customer is billed monthly.

Is there anything I have missed? Can you think of Indian online businesses who communicate effectively in such scenarios?

Why we say Yes and How to say No

Cover of

Cover via Amazon

On Dave McClure‘s recommendation, I recently read one of the most amazing book on understanding human beings and marketing – Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion by Robert B. Cialdini. It’s an interesting read and Robert does a good job explaining the weapons of influence (why we say yes) backed with real life case studies and strategies to defend from the same (how to say no). Noted below are the six universal principles explained in the book.

  • Reciprocation: The rule says that we should try to reply, in kind, what another person has provided us. We are obligated to the future repayment of favors, gifts, invitations, and the like.
  • Commitment & Consistency: The rule says that we have an obsessive desire to be (and to appear) consistent with what we have already done. Once we have made a choice or taken a stand, we will encounter personal and interpersonal pressures to behave consistently with that commitment.
  • Social Proof: It’s our tendency to see an action as more appropriate when others are doing it normally.
  • Liking: The rule says that we most prefer to say yes to requests of someone we know and like.
  • Authority: The rule says that we have a deep-seated sense of duty to authority within us all.
  • Scarcity: The rule says that the idea of potential loss plays a large role in human decision making. We are more motivated by the thought of losing something than by the thought of gaining something of equal value.

There are many examples that Robert mentions in the book that greatly enhance our ability to appreciate these principles. One such example is described below.

In a study, a set of home owners was incentivized to reduce home energy consumption by publicizing their names in local newspaper articles as public-spirited, fuel-conserving citizens. Another set was just told about the benefits of energy conservation and encouraged to do the same. The first set, much to our expectation, reduced energy consumption by the end of the study. However, interesting to note was the fact that these set of homeowners continue to reduce energy consumption even beyond the incentive period. The necessity to consistently behave as per previous public commitment proved to have a lasting impact on these homeowners.

Other than the examples mentioned in the book, I’ve come across two such examples that knowingly (or unknowingly) use one of the above mentioned principle:

  • Jason Calacanis in his famous Jason’s List mentions “This reciprication effect is a natural part of our existence, and there is nothing wrong with it. Just this week someone who attended a tech meetup at Mahalo met me in a bar and bought me and my father a drink. We talked for 30 minutes, and now for the cost of $15 in drinks I would take that guy’s call any time. How could I not–it would be rude!”. Read complete post on Business Insider.
  • Steve Cheney in his recent post notes “Group buying also does an incredible job creating perceived scarcity”.

I’m now actively trying to use these principles in areas such as negotiation and networking. Have you used Robert’s principles to influence others? Or are you planning to use? I would love to hear them.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Why You Should Get a Mac?

I’ve been responsible for increasing productivity for many of my friends by convincing them to switch to Mac from PC. Every time I engage in an conversation, I find that there are so many misconceptions people have about Mac. As for me, I moved to Mac on 25th July 2009 after experiencing Mac on my HP laptop. It’s not perfectly legal to do so but I installed (hackintosh) to experience Mac. And being an iPhone owner really helped me appreciate Mac and it took me no time to get one of my own. Now, let’s get some things clear.

Myth # 1: It’s not easy to use

Perhaps, Mac is the easiest OS to use. The trackpad’s multi-touch interface makes it super easy to scroll documents and view photos. You can even pinch to zoom in and out.

Myth # 2: It’s not easy to switch from PC

Well, some things are easier to forget. You will be amazed how quickly you will forget PC after you switch to Mac. There is nothing to learn to use Mac. Just click on the icons on the dock to know about the various applications and settings. And yes, there’s even a right click on Mac! Still not convinced, know the basic difference between a PC and a Mac in this video.

Myth # 3: There are no applications for Mac

Most of the applications are out of the box. iLife (iPhoto, iMovie), iTunes, Safari, iChat for managing photos, music, browsing and chatting. You would not need to download any more software for normal usage. However, there are many applications designed for Mac. Not to mention, your favorite PC applications are always available on Mac. Heck, you can even run windows on Mac for those obscure PC only applications.

Myth # 4: There is not much support available

Trust me, you wouldn’t need one. In case you need, Apple’s award winning support is just a phone call away. I bought my Macbook Pro from US and had upgraded the RAM to 4GB. But unfortunately, the technician somehow missed upgrading the RAM (yeah, that was strange! Do check before leaving the store!) and I got to know only when I was in India. I called support and they shipped the RAM from Singapore to India within 3 days!

Myth # 5: It’s expensive

Sure, you can get an out of date windows laptop for $150. And a decent one would cost around $500. But, the direct costs of an anti-virus, firewall etc would add to your total cost. Not to forget, the opportunity cost when after a month, the PC will become too slow to boot and becomes really sluggish on opening multiple applications. Trust me, that’s one of the reason, Soluto won the recent TechCrunch Disrupt award. And their tagline says it all – “Anti-Frustration Software”.

Still with me? Now, here are top 4 reasons for you to get a Mac.

# 1: No hang

At some point of time in our lives, we have been victims of the blue death screen. However, by owning the complete user experience (hardware and software), Apple has been able to build one of the most efficient laptop. Of course, there are applications that sometime hang but that’s nothing to do with OS.

# 2: No virus

You won’t need an anti-virus and need not worry every about using your friend’s USB drive.

# 3: Extended Battery Life

Macbook has one of the best batteries. Mine lasts about 4.5 hours on full charge even after 10 months of usage.

# 4: Small Details Matter

From backlit keyboard to magsafe power port to unibody enclosure to spotlight to Expose, all are designed keeping YOU in mind.

The above is just an indicative list to help you explore Mac. There are many other things which you will appreciate as you experience Mac. And if you have any further questions, do let me know in comments. I would be more than happy to assist you in your transformational journey from PC to Mac!

How to make your employees use your products?

Nick Wingfield has an interesting story on WSJ touching one of the most intriguing topics – Employer’s stance towards workers’ personal use of competitor products.

The perils of being an iPhone user at Microsoft were on display last September. At an all- company meeting in a Seattle sports stadium, one hapless employee used his iPhone to snap photos of Microsoft Chief Executive Steve Ballmer. Mr. Ballmer snatched the iPhone out of the employee’s hands, placed it on the ground and pretended to stomp on it in front of thousands of Microsoft workers, according to people present. Mr. Ballmer uses phones from different manufacturers that run on Microsoft’s mobile phone software.

via online.wsj.com

To view employees unfavorably or discriminate because of their use of competitor products or services is clearly not a good practice for any organization. No matter how bad it hurts seeing your own employees using competitor products, it’s often always best not to confront directly and certainly not make it a policy. However, one could adopt one or more of the many approaches to promote usage among the company. Some of these are outlined below.

  • Give it free or at reduced price: Google recently gave a Nexus One phone free to all of its employees before the actual launch of the phone. Not only this tactic resulted in improving employee happiness quotient but also provided the company free publicity with everyone talking about it with their friends/family.
  • Make everyone a product manager: In the early stages of the product in an already established market, the cost of switching existing users to your own product can be quite high. By promoting employees to contribute ideas towards improving the product not only ensures usage but also greater buy-in among the employees.
  • Use it internally: Using the product internally often helps identification of problems early resulting in a more robust product. By using the product within your own organization successfully is the best proof of concept that the product in fact works and provides Sales the necessary confidence to sell outside.
  • Be passionate: The truth is if you are not passionate about it, the world too will not be passionate. Steve Jobs is known for the famous product launches emphasizing words such as “incredible”, “amazing” and “awesome” at least a dozen times within a keynote address.

If you are a policy maker in your organization, think before you want to outright ban / discourage use of competitor products. There are obviously better options.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Is your company ready to adopt “Work from Home” model?

Toni Schneider (CEO, Automattic) has an excellent post describing the reasons for a company to have a distributed team.

I’ve noticed a new trend in Silicon Valley. More and more startups are beginning life as distributed companies, and investors and partners are starting to accept it as normal. Our company Automattic is distributed, and I’m ready to sing the praises of running a business in this way. BTW, I think distributed (“evenly spread throughout an area”) is a better description than the more commonly used virtual (“nearly real or simulated to be real”) for a company that has people working from all over the place instead of a centralized office. In Automattic’s case, we currently have over 50 employees spread across 12 US states and 10 countries.

via toni.org

A follow up post by Bob Patterson describes the cost and and time saving benefits of a distributed company model.

With NO Commute – so they get hours of time back a day. Let’s say 2 hours a day. 10 hours a week. 40 hours a month. (That’s a working week). 12 weeks a year! That is a lot of dentist visits, plumber visits, time with kids and spouse, time to nap, time to do whatever. And all this time was pulled out of the air as a result of not commuting.

Then of course there are the direct costs of commuting – the car, the transport. It costs $9,000 a year to run a car fully costed. How about coffee and lunch? What do you spend today? $5.0 – $20 a day. That is $1,000 – $4,000 a year for coffee and lunch! How about clothes? I used to buy 2 suits a year as a man. Women can’t get away with that. How much does going to work cost you in clothes? $2,000 – $5,000.

via fastforwardblog.com

I couldn’t agree more with Toni and Bob. I’m personally a strong proponent of “Work from home” model. However, there are many reasons why this model doesn’t work in many organizations. For those organizations, one or more of the below points stands true:

  • People feel far too comfortable walking to the other person and talking face to face rather than picking a phone and do the talk. They feel more confident in convincing/communicating others face to face.
  • If majority of the employees don’t exercise the work from home flexibility, then there always a fear that those exercising may be treated indiscriminately by their managers.
  • In case of no deadlines and/or clear accountability, those exercising the work from home option often tend to relax at home, resulting in lower productivity.
  • Companies don’t pay for number of projects done but for number of hours clocked.
  • Companies believe strongly in cubicles and glass doors that differentiate employees.
  • Employees want to exercise authority/control over others.

What other reasons can you think?

There is no “back” button, only a “next” button

Noam Cohen has an interesting article in NYTimes questioning the premise that social networks are bringing us together. She tries to answer this using ChatRoulette as a case study. It’s an interesting read and recommended one if you have five minutes to spare. I have noted the main points below:

  • ChatRoulette as “a probabilistic community” that “relies on the transitory connections between users that cannot be maintained beyond the initial period of contact.”
  • Tim Hwang, co-author of a study of ChatRoulette describes it as “..a social network that’s not a social network.”
  • “It doesn’t spread in the way that social networks normally spread, through social connections and strong sustained communities,”
  • ChatRoulette may never move beyond faddish interest. Mr. Hwang, however, counts himself a ChatRoulette optimist, arguing that the service will inevitably become more like other social networks and lose its radical anonymity and chaotic spirit.

It’s hard to make out what the site will be in the next year or so. As Fred Wilson puts it – “Is this the adult friend finder 2.0 or Facebook 2.0?”

I believe ChatRoulette is too simplistic in it’s current avatar – doesn’t require a login, no friends to be added, no address book import, no software to be installed to chat. And has the component of “instant gratification” – you see a lot and move on if you don’t like the other person. However, the underlying principle of anonymity is what makes the site popular. This also means that community can not be monitored by it’s members and more often than not good members (genuinely interested in knowing others) will eventually leave the community, leaving behind a pile of not-so-good members. I have already left!

UQAVBRJSW85W

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

What to expect in an interview for Product Manager?

Off late I’ve spent a lot of time interviewing candidates for Product Manager position. I have tried to list down some of the common questions I ask along with possible line of answers for most of the questions. Personal Questions mentioned below may not be specific to Product Management but are nonetheless important. It’s important for me (the interviewer) to know your (the candidate) thought process in real life situations. Hence, I almost always mention specific situation for each question.

Product Management

  • What is the metric you track?
    • Apart from the common web metrics such as unique visitors and pageviews, one should also mention business specific metric. Often, I will ask this question for a specific business. I do not expect the candidate to know the inner working of the business. However, I do want to know what they think would be an important metric if they were to run that business.
  • How do you segment the data?
    • More often than not, I haven’t seen candidates go beyond standard segmentation such as demographic and source of traffic. Though segmentation is business specific but one could think segmenting users based on their online behavior (readers Vs contributors etc), potential value to the business, etc.
  • How do you know your customers are happy?
    • This one is a little tricky. In fact, the question is incomplete. There can be many metric which can help us answer this but it would depend on the type of product/service. For example, average time spent/PVs per visit on the site can be good for some sites (such as social networks) but for information searching sites (such as classifieds etc) this could mean too many intermediate steps before the final call to action. One good measure that usually works for most sites is how many users are willing to recommend your product/service to others.
  • How would you improve a particular product?
    • This could be any product and not necessarily the product you have been working on for the past year. I’m more interested in knowing your thought process rather than the actual improvements you suggest. So it’s important to think ALOUD.
  • What would you do if one day your PageViews are down by 30%?
    • This is one of the sample case study. I want to see the thought process. How you break the problem? How do you analyze? This is followed by more case studies covering various scenarios.
  • What do you do if the engineering team says “not possible” to the feature you love the most?
    • I want to see how you react at first to such situations and ways adopted to find alternative solutions.
  • How do you convince others of your ideas?
    • I want to know how you persuade others. What are the techniques you adopt for convincing others? Is there a different strategy for your boss vs co-workers?
  • Why did you enter market X when Y is clearly the market leader? (this is based on candidate’s resume)
    • If that is something you have done, I want to understand the reasons behind it. Was the market big enough? How big it is? Why do you think you would succeed? Was there any unmet need that you identified? Was your product different? If yes, why wouldn’t the competitor copy it? How long they would take?

Personal Questions (not specific to product management)

  • What are you most proud of in your current job? Or, looking back two years, what are you most proud of?
    • This one requires a little introspection on part of the candidate. One line of thought could be to summarize your achievements and tie them with a common thread.
  • Why this job?
    • This may be the most common question to expect, yet many candidates give reasons such as salary, location and/or bad boss among others. Try finding a real good reason before appearing for an interview. One line of thought could be how the prospective job could help you in your long term goal. Yes, it’s important to know where you want to be in the short term (2-5 years) and in the long run.
    • Grab this opportunity to show your research about the organization. Have you talked to current employees? What do they say? How about talking to customers? You will be surprised to see how much interviewer would love to hear this from you.
    • Golden rule is not to say anything negative about your current/past organization. The negativity can be expressed in a positive manner. Instead of saying people are rigid and there exists too many processes to follow, one could say that I want to join an organization where I can leverage my creativity in solving problems.
  • Why we should hire you?
    • If you have ever sold something, this should be easy. The interviewer is asking you to literally sell yourself. It’s important you answer this within two minutes, otherwise the interviewer may lost you. Think the skill sets you have and how those skill sets could be beneficial to the role you are applying. Don’t mention standard stuff such as your educational qualification (unless it’s very unique, yet relevant to the job). Instead use this opportunity to demonstrate the fit between your abilities and employer’s need.
  • Why did you decide to shift from engineering to product? (for role switchers)
    • It’s common for candidates to move from engineering to product. Many organizations encourage this and it’s a good thing to happen. However, the important thing is for you to articulate the reasons for the shift. Reasons such as this was a logical progression for me or I was tired of coding are not the reasons you would want to say in an interview.
    • It would also be good to show how your engineering background/experience is helping you in product. Or is proving to be a disadvantage at times.
  • If given an offer, would you be willing to join at the same or below your current salary?
    • Yes, I actually ask this question. More often than not, towards the end of the interview, it’s generally known that candidate would lack at certain skills or would need to pick up certain skills. Do not allow the interviewer to take advantage of this situation. I want to know how you can be diplomatic under such situations.

Point of Caution

  • Be ethical
    • You should never reveal any details about the company which is not in the public domain. If your company is public, be sure to read the annual report and share only information that’s presented there. For information not in public domain, don’t reveal absolute numbers. Instead, share relative percentages and always provide a range. Say, between 10 to 25% rather than saying 15% (or between 60 and 110 instead of saying 80). If the interviewer is pressing you hard for absolute numbers, don’t give up. Most likely, this is a trapped interview where interviewer is only interested in knowing your employer’s internal information.

The above list may not be exhaustive but I have tried my best to cover as many questions as I can. Let me know in comments what are your favorite questions.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Saurabh Arora is settling down in NYC before the mayhem starts in few days. He is an ordinary guy who in his most recent role got his hands dirty doing product development, online customer acquisition, product marketing and online revenue generation for one of the leading online job portal.

Read more | Social Networks |  Email |  Short Blog
Subscribe
RSS  Subscribe to my RSS Feed
Twitter  Follow me on Twitter

Email Updates  Enter your email address:


Flickr Photostream  more
Sorry Verizon! Hard luck. This doesn't change anything. Try sell iPhone Creating an emotional connect Creating an emotional connect Creating an emotional connect Creating an emotional connect Creating an emotional connect Yahoo's recent facebook gamble Google and Bing search results for world cup 

Recent Tweets

follow me on twitter

Schedule a meeting


Call me

Or directly call me at +1.347.746.2335

Reader Census

Powered by Hunch.com